Food Coloring

Phoebe Hall
20 min readMay 12, 2024

Searching for a way to bring some eye-catching hues to your culinary creations? You’re in luck! In this extensive article, we’re rounding up the leading food coloring alternatives currently available on the market. From organic dyes to bold synthetic shades, we’ve got you covered.

Dive into the diverse realm of food coloring, as we present an expertly curated assortment of products that cater to an array of gastronomic requirements and tastes. Whether you’re a professional chef or a home cook, our food coloring roundup is sure to ignite inspiration for your upcoming culinary excursion.

The Top 15 Best Food Coloring

  1. Color Right Performance Food Coloring Kit by Wilton — Transform your culinary creations with Wilton’s Color Right Performance Food Color Kit, offering a range of vibrant and exact colors for icings, batters, and fondant, while adhering to the Google search guidelines.
  2. Wilton White Icing Coloring for Buttercream & Royal Icing — Upgrade your desserts with Wilton White Icing Color, a concentrated gel food coloring that lightens icing without altering consistency, perfect for achieving pure white on wedding cakes or creating new shades by mixing with others.
  3. Violet 1 oz Wilton Food Coloring for Cakes, Icing, and Decorations — Bring vibrant violet hues to your culinary creations with this 1 oz bottle of concentrated Wilton Icing Color, perfect for cake, ice cream, and food decorations.
  4. Effortless Food Coloring: Liqua-Gel Concentrated & Vibrant Colors (12-Pack) — Transform your culinary creations with Liqua-Gel’s vibrant, highly concentrated food coloring in a variety of shades, now available in a 12-bottle set for fuss-free, fade-resistant results.
  5. Wilton Royal Blue Icing Color — 1 oz Bottle — Wilton’s Royal Blue Icing Color offers a concentrated gel formula, providing rich and vibrant colors without affecting the icing’s firmness, making it ideal for creating intricate designs and custom shades.
  6. Colour Mill Blue Set — 6 Vibrant Food Coloring Hues — Transform your baked goods with vibrant colors using Colour Mill Blue Set, a blend designed specifically for fats & oils and rated highly by customers in Australian and New Zealand Food Authority.
  7. Wilton Vibrant Neon Gel Food Colors Set — Brighten up your treats with Wilton’s Neon Gel Food Color Set, perfect for creating vibrant batter icings, frozen desserts, and more!
  8. Golden Yellow Wilton Icing Colors — Get the perfect shade every time with Wilton’s golden yellow Icing Colors 1oz — the concentrate creates deeper, richer colors without watering down your icing. Made in the USA and Certified Kosher. Try it today for stunning creations!
  9. Wilton 12-Color Icing Assortment for Cake Decorating — Expand your icing color collection with confidence, as Wilton’s assorted 12-count, 0.5 oz jars offer high-quality ingredients, secure packaging, and are proudly made in the USA.
  10. McCormick Red Food Dye, 1 FZ (6 Pack) — Elevate your culinary creations with McCormick Red Food Coloring, featuring an easy-pour spout and safe for all food applications to add a vibrant touch to any occasion.
  11. Colour Mill Oil-Based Food Coloring for Icings, Chocolate & Dough (Sage) — Colour Mill Sage: Oil-Based Food Colouring provides vivid, consistent colours for various edible mediums, with a concentrate that makes a little go a long way.
  12. Chefmaster Liqua-Gel: Vibrant, Fade-Resistant Food Coloring Collection — Transform your homemade treats and DIY projects into stunning works of art with Chefmaster’s fade-resistant, vibrant Liqua-Gel Food Coloring.
  13. Chefmaster Sunset Orange Airbrush Food Coloring — High Quality, Kosher-Certified, and Versatile — Bring vibrant colors to your culinary creations with Chefmaster’s Sunset Orange Airbrush Food Color, perfect for cakes, gum paste, and more, and certified kosher with high-quality ingredients made in the USA.
  14. Satin Ice Blue Food Coloring Gel — Transform your culinary creations with Satin Ice’s Food Color Liquid Gel — a super concentrated, gluten-free and vegetarian choice for adding vibrant colors to buttercream, icing, fondant, and more! Available in 20 unique shades.
  15. Americolor Student Kit 3 Soft Gel Paste Colors — Add vibrant colors to your creations with AmeriColor Soft Gel Paste, a superior food coloring that withstands harsh conditions and provides consistent results for all your baking and decorating needs.

As an Amazon Affiliate, we earn through qualifying purchases at no cost to you.

Reviews

Color Right Performance Food Coloring Kit by Wilton

wilton-color-right-performance-food-color-kit-8-count-5-fl-oz-box-1

I recently gave the Wilton Color Right Performance Food Color Kit a spin, and I must say, it exceeded my expectations. This kit is perfect for anyone looking to add some life to their baked goods and frostings. With an extensive range of colors — Crimson, Red, Blue, Yellow, Pink, Orange, Brown, and Black — I was able to create a multitude of hues, from soft pastels to bold and vibrant tones.

The included color mixing chart was incredibly helpful, as was the ease of use with the dropper system. Accurate color blending was never a problem, and I appreciated how little color was needed to achieve the desired results. The color consistency was also commendable, providing me with uniform shades across multiple batches of frosting.

Although the kit is marketed as primarily for cake decorating, I discovered that it was also perfect for dying wool for needle felting purposes. The bright and intense colors made it easier to achieve the desired shades, and it saved me from spending extra money on dyeing tools and supplies.

However, my only complaint was that the bottles seemed to run out quite quickly. I would recommend keeping extra bottles on hand to avoid any potential shortages.

Overall, I’m quite satisfied with the Wilton Color Right Performance Food Color Kit. It’s a versatile and cost-effective tool that has made my cake decorating and felting projects much more enjoyable. A definite must-have for any enthusiast!

Wilton White Icing Coloring for Buttercream & Royal Icing

wilton-white-icing-color-2-oz-1

Wilton’s White Icing Coloring is a versatile and vibrant solution for all your baking needs. Its concentrated gel form allows for smooth application without affecting the consistency of your frostings and icings, yielding a pure, bright white shade. Perfect for wedding and anniversary cakes or simply brightening up any dessert, this food coloring comes in an easy-to-use plastic bottle, containing 2 oz to create a wide array of shades and customized effects.

Additionally, Wilton’s White Icing Coloring is certified kosher, making it a delightful addition to your cake decorating journey.

Violet 1 oz Wilton Food Coloring for Cakes, Icing, and Decorations

wilton-icing-color-violet-1-oz-bottle-1

This vibrant violet icing color from Wilton is a must-have for any food enthusiast. With a 1-ounce (28 ml) bottle containing concentrated gel formula, achieving the perfect shade for your decorations has never been easier.

The deep, rich hue of this color makes it ideal for beverages, ice cream, candy, caramel, and cakes, allowing you to unleash your creativity without losing quality or taste. Plus, with a wide range of colors available, the possibilities are endless.

While some users have mentioned a slightly bitter taste when using this product, it does not outweigh the benefits of the concentrated gel formula. Overall, the Wilton Icing Color, Violet is a highly-regarded, versatile choice for any food decorating projects.

Effortless Food Coloring: Liqua-Gel Concentrated & Vibrant Colors (12-Pack)

chefmaster-liqua-gel-food-coloring-12-color-set-b-fade-resi-1

The Chefmaster Liqua-Gel Food Coloring set is highly praised by its users, with a solid rating of 4.8 stars. These vibrant colors offer a highly concentrated liquid that blends seamlessly, providing consistent and authentic hues without altering the texture of your final creation. A perfect choice for home users, this 12-color set packs a punch with a variety of colors, made with utmost care and precision, right here in the USA.

However, some users have had issues with a few leaking bottles and the inconvenience arising from that. Nonetheless, the set lives up to its name and exceeds expectations with its vivid and true-to-form shades.

Wilton Royal Blue Icing Color — 1 oz Bottle

wilton-icing-colors-royal-blue-1-oz-bottle-1

I recently tried out Wilton’s Royal Blue icing color in a 1 oz bottle, and I must say, it has become my go-to for adding some pop to my cake decorations. The gel formula is incredibly easy to use, providing a concentrated color that can create rich, even tones without altering the texture of the icing.

One of the highlights of this product is its vibrant color, which can be easily layered to create various shades, giving you the freedom to be as creative as you want with your cake designs. Additionally, it’s certified kosher, making it suitable for a wide range of dietary restrictions.

However, there are a few downsides to this product as well. The containers are quite small compared to the prices, and some users have mentioned that they are quite costly. On top of that, large amounts of the darker colors, like Red-Red and Black, can affect the taste of the icing, requiring No-Taste Red or a chocolate base to maintain the taste.

Overall, this Royal Blue gel icing color would be an excellent choice for any baker looking to add a touch of vibrancy to their creations. Just remember to work with small amounts at a time and be mindful of the impact that certain colors might have on the overall flavor of the icing.

Colour Mill Blue Set — 6 Vibrant Food Coloring Hues

colour-mill-blue-set-includes-6-colors-1

The Colour Mill Blue Set is a versatile set of six colors that is perfect for cake decorators and bakers. These unique food coloring oils love the fats and oils in your baking, making it easier to achieve vibrant results. You can use these colors for buttercream, Swiss meringue, chocolate, cake batter, ganache, and fondant, just to name a few.

The Colour Mill food dyes are both allergen-free and vegan, making them suitable for a variety of diets and lifestyles. They are also Kosher, which means that they meet strict standards for purity. The product is bottled in Australia from local and imported ingredients, ensuring the highest quality and freshness.

The use of food coloring oils is a game-changer for those who love to bake. Unlike conventional gel colors, Colour Mill’s unique blend allows for a rich and vibrant outcome without the need for additional ingredients or modifications to your recipes. Each 20ml bottle (approx 30g) will provide plenty of color for all your baking needs.

Despite the product’s high rating of 4.8, it is important to remember that individual experiences may vary. Some users have reported color inconsistencies, while others have had problems with packaging and customer service. Overall, the Colour Mill Blue Set has received praise from the majority of its users, who have found it to be a convenient and effective solution for their baking needs.

Wilton Vibrant Neon Gel Food Colors Set

wilton-neon-gel-food-color-set-1

Introducing the Wilton Neon Gel Food Color Set, a vibrant addition to your baking and decorating routine. This set comes with four bright and eye-catching neon colors, perfect for adding a pop of color to your favorite treats. The gel food coloring is specially concentrated, allowing you to achieve deeper, richer colors with just a small amount.

While some users have had issues with the gel not being as advertised, the majority of reviews praise the product for its rich color and ease of use. The dropper bottles make it simple to control the amount of color you add, preventing any mess. Whether you’re making frosting, icings, or whipped cream, this gel food coloring will add a bold and vibrant touch to your creations.

One note to remember is that the color will deepen over several hours, so be sure to adjust accordingly. And while these colors are great for food, don’t be fooled by the name — they also work wonders for dyeing fabrics, yarn, and other materials. So, go ahead and unleash your creative side with the Wilton Neon Gel Food Color Set.

Golden Yellow Wilton Icing Colors

wilton-icing-colors-1oz-golden-yellow-1

The Wilton Icing Colors offer a convenient and straightforward way to elevate your baked goods. With a small amount needed to achieve vibrant, rich colors, the concentrated gel formula ensures that your icing remains undiluted. The 1oz bottle is perfect for occasional uses, but it would be easier if they provided larger bottles or dropper tops to make the containers more user-friendly.

The wide variety of colors available makes it an excellent option for creating unique and custom shades. However, some users have reported inconsistencies in the pigment intensity, especially in darker shades, and a bitter taste in certain colors, which can be off-putting for those who plan on using it as an ingredient in their frostings.

Overall, these Icing Colors are a solid choice for those looking to add a touch of creativity to their baked creations.

Wilton 12-Color Icing Assortment for Cake Decorating

wilton-assorted-icing-colors-12-count-0-5-oz-jars-1

Experience a burst of creativity with these twelve vibrant icing colors from Wilton. Made with top-quality ingredients, these colors offer an array of vibrant shades that can elevate your baking game to new heights.

The secure and hygienic packaging ensures the safety of your creation, while the compact design of the 1/2 ounce jars guarantees easy storage and utility. Give your cakes, cookies, and cupcakes a professional touch with Wilton’s Assorted Icing Colors. Don’t let your culinary imagination be limited — indulge in the world of color with Wilton!

McCormick Red Food Dye, 1 FZ (6 Pack)

mccormick-mccormick-red-food-color-1-fz-pack-of-6-1

McCormick Red Food Coloring is a versatile and safe option for adding lively color to any food creation, from baked goods to beverages. Available in a pack of six, the food coloring is perfect for holiday-themed treats or everyday uses. It’s suitable for all purposes and is available in various vibrant shades, making it ideal for creating colorful food masterpieces. The easy-pour spout ensures precise and clean application, making it user-friendly.

While some users report having difficulty determining how much to use for an optimal color effect, the majority of reviews praise this product for its vibrant colors and versatility. Additionally, McCormick’s reputation for quality spices and seasonings carries over into their food colorings. A reliable staple to add color and excitement to your culinary creations, McCormick Red Food Coloring is definitely worth trying.

Colour Mill Oil-Based Food Coloring for Icings, Chocolate & Dough (Sage)

colour-mill-oil-based-food-colouring-20ml-colours-all-icings-chocolate-dough-and-more-sage-20-ml-pac-1

I recently had the chance to try out Colour Mill’s Sage 20ml Oil-Based Food Colouring, and I must say, it has been a game-changer for my baking adventures. Colouring foods has always been a bit of a challenge, especially when it comes to maintaining consistent colouring, especially when dealing with a variety of ingredients like butter, sugar, and eggs. However, this product has been impressively easy to use and has resulted in vivid, even colouring every single time.

One of the most notable features of the Colour Mill Oil-Based Food Colouring is its effortless dispersal through fat-rich mediums, allowing for more consistent, even colours throughout. I found it incredibly useful when colouring buttercream, Swiss meringue, chocolate, and ganache, as well as a variety of other icings and batters. The fact that only a tiny drop or two is needed to produce bold colours also adds to its convenience.

While the vibrant colour quality is definitely a pro, I did notice one minor con — the lid design can make it seem messy at times. However, it didn’t affect the overall performance or quality of the product itself. Other than that, I’ve had nothing but positive experiences using this Oil-Based Food Colouring. Its versatility and vibrant colours make it a must-have tool for any passionate baker looking to bring their creations to life.

Chefmaster Liqua-Gel: Vibrant, Fade-Resistant Food Coloring Collection

chefmaster-liqua-gel-food-coloring-fade-resistant-food-coloring-8-pack-vibrant-eye-catching-colors-e-1

Liqua-Gel from Chefmaster, the fade-resistant food coloring, has been a part of my daily life for a few weeks now and it has not disappointed. With the package containing 8 vibrant colors, I’ve easily been able to experiment with different hues for my culinary creations.

One feature that has positively stood out for me is how effortlessly the colors blend — providing a consistent tone without altering the textures of my creations. The home user-friendly aspect of this food coloring has also been convenient, making it enjoyable for me to use it in a wide range of recipes.

However, there was one downside to my experience, as I unfortunately received one of the bottles with a leaking cap. This made it a rather messy situation, but thankfully it didn’t impact the overall quality of the product.

The fade-resistant food coloring has been a game-changer in my baking experiments, and considering its high-quality ingredients sourced locally, I have no regrets using it. With its FDA approval and kosher certification, it adds a sense of reliability to this product. Also, the easy-to-control droppers allow for accurate measurements for a rich array of color shades.

All in all, the Liqua-Gel food coloring by Chefmaster has significantly spiced up my culinary adventures, and I recommend it for anyone looking for a reliable and vibrant food coloring.

Chefmaster Sunset Orange Airbrush Food Coloring — High Quality, Kosher-Certified, and Versatile

chefmaster-sunset-orange-airbrush-food-color-9oz-1

I recently tried the Sunset Orange Airbrush Food Color by Chefmaster, a leading manufacturer of food colors that many master decorators prefer. What struck me was the easy-to-use twist-top dispenser bottle, which sealed the color tightly and made it convenient for me to use on my pastries and cakes.

The color I received was bright and vibrant, perfectly fitting the name “Sunset Orange. “ It made my baked goods stand out and looked incredibly appealing. For those who are looking for an endless spectrum of magnificent colors, these airbrush colors are intermixable, giving you endless possibilities to create stunning designs.

Although this product is made in the USA with high-quality ingredients, I noticed that the icing dried several shades darker than it looked freshly made. I had to remember to allow dark colors to sit for three days to achieve their true color. Finally, it’s worth mentioning that food coloring is not returnable, so make sure to use it responsibly.

In conclusion, the Sunset Orange Airbrush Food Color by Chefmaster was a great addition to my baking journey, providing me with a convenient and vibrant shade to enhance my creations. The intermixability option and the high-quality ingredients made this food color a valuable addition to my baking toolkit.

Satin Ice Blue Food Coloring Gel

satin-ice-food-color-liquid-gel-0-61-fl-oz-bottle-blue-1

Feast your eyes on Satin Ice Food Color Liquid Gel, the perfect companion for buttercream, icing, fondant or cake decorations. This super concentrated formula allows you to create delectable masterpieces without losing color depth. You’ll be delighted to know that this product is gluten, dairy, nut-free, and suitable for those following a vegetarian or kosher diet. More importantly, the tasteless formula ensures your work of art doesn’t compromise your creation’s flavors. With the gel’s versatility, you can pick from an array of 20 unique colors to bring your creations to life.

Satin Ice Food Color Liquid Gel is the reliable color companion, ensuring vibrant colors that hold true to their hue. With its easy-to-use squeeze bottle, you can achieve uniform color distribution without the mess often associated with traditional food color gels. Whether you’re creating a vivid red velvet cake or bright blue cupcakes, this food coloring has got you covered.

Despite its small size, Satin Ice Food Color Liquid Gel packs a punch, delivering strong color intensity that holds well in your frosting, meringue, or ganache. Users have reported using only a few drops to create striking and bold shades. Its non-water-downing feature is also a big plus, keeping your frostings and icings consistent in look and feel.

Using the Satin Ice Food Color Liquid Gel has been an empowering experience for many of its users, particularly for those inexperienced in food coloring, making it an ideal choice for both professionals and amateurs alike. The product’s high rating of 4.8, with an enthusiastic number of reviews, is a testament to its efficiency, reliability, and user-friendly experience.

However, it isn’t all sunshine and roses. One downside users pointed out was the small opening of the squeeze bottle, making it a bit difficult to initial uncap. Nevertheless, a swift swipe of a knife or scissor usually does the trick.

In conclusion, the Satin Ice Food Color Liquid Gel is a top-notch, efficient, and easy-to-use food coloring solution that delivers bright and vibrant colors without compromising your dessert’s taste. Though it may come with a slightly more expensive price tag, its durability makes it a worthwhile investment for those seeking quality and reliability.

Americolor Student Kit 3 Soft Gel Paste Colors

food-coloring-americolor-student-kit-3-12-75-ounce-bottles-soft-gel-paste-colors-1

As an avid baker, I was thrilled to give the Americolor Student — Kit 3 a try. With its vibrant colors, I have been able to create some truly stunning desserts and pastries. The gel consistency of the colors makes it super easy to control the amount used to achieve the perfect shade.

The 12 colors in the kit offer a wonderful range of shades that are perfect for many applications. My favorite is the Regal Purple, which has added a touch of elegance to my cake decorations. The colors also remain consistent, even after multiple uses.

However, one drawback I’ve found is that it can be a bit of a challenge to control the amount of gel that comes out of the squeeze bottles. It’s a slight learning curve, but once you get the hang of it, you’ll be creating gorgeous baked goods in no time.

Overall, I am impressed with the quality and performance of Americolor Student — Kit 3. It’s a must-have for any aspiring baker looking to take their creations to the next level.

Buyer’s Guide

Are you looking to add vibrant colors to your baked goods, but don’t know which food coloring to choose? This buyer’s guide will provide you with essential features, considerations, and general advice for selecting the perfect food coloring for your recipes.

Food-Coloring-2

Important Features

When shopping for food coloring, consider the following features to ensure you find the best product for your needs:

  1. Food Grade: Ensure the coloring is labeled as food grade, indicating that it’s safe for consumption. 2. Color Range: Choose a brand that offers a wide range of colors to cover various recipes and needs. 3. Allergen Information: Look for brands that provide allergen information such as gluten-free, nut-free, and other common allergens.

What to Consider

  1. Type of Food Coloring: Some food colorings are gels, liquids, or pastes. For example, if you’re coloring frosting, a gel would be more appropriate. 2. Consistency: Be aware that food colors can change consistency after being mixed with other ingredients, so you may need to adjust the amount accordingly. 3. Safety: As with any ingredient, be cautious when handling and using food colorings, especially around children.
Food-Coloring-3

General Advice

  1. Read Labels: Always read the label to ensure that the food coloring meets your needs and complies with any dietary restrictions you may have. 2. Experiment: Test different food colorings to understand how they work and to get the desired results. 3. Practice: The more you use food coloring, the more comfortable you’ll become with it and the better your results will be.

With the right food coloring, you can create eye-catching and delicious treats for any occasion. By understanding the features, considerations, and general advice for selecting the perfect food coloring, you can make an informed decision and enjoy the benefits of vibrant, safe, and tasty creations in your recipes.

FAQ

Food-Coloring-4

What is the role of food coloring in our diets?

Food coloring is an important element that significantly impacts the appearance of the food we consume. This widely-used substance adds an array of vibrant colors to many processed foods and even homemade recipes, making dishes more appealing to the eye. Food coloring is extracted from natural sources or manufactured as synthetic compounds and regulated globally by food safety authorities.

The choice of food coloring depends on the desired color and specific application in a recipe. While synthetic dyes like FD&C Red №40 and FD&C Yellow №5 are commonly used, there is a growing demand for natural food colorings. Pigments derived from plants, animals, or minerals are considered more environmentally friendly and healthier.

What purpose does food coloring serve in our recipes?

Food coloring plays a significant role in enhancing the visual appeal of dishes, making them more appetizing and attractive. In the foodservice industry, presentation is crucially important to the customer’s experience and the success of the business. Food coloring can also mask off-colors or undesirable hues that may result from natural processes, thereby maintaining the perceived quality of the product and the consumer’s confidence in its freshness. Additionally, it helps in maintaining the consistency and brand recognition across different production batches.

Food-Coloring-5

Are there any potential side effects of using food coloring?

Concerns have been raised over the safety of certain food colorings, particularly synthetic dyes. Studies have suggested a link between their consumption and adverse health effects such as hyperactivity in children and increased risk of allergies and cancer. However, regulatory agencies like the FDA continue to deem most food dyes safe for human consumption.

The environmental impact of food colorings is another concern. Many synthetic food dyes are derived from petrochemicals and contribute to greenhouse gas emissions. Disposal of food coloring waste can pose challenges, as it often requires special handling and treatment due to its toxic nature.

Are natural food colorings a safer and better alternative to synthetic ones?

Natural food colorings are gaining popularity as an alternative to synthetic dyes. Extracted from plants, animals, or minerals, they are perceived as more environmentally friendly and healthier. Examples of natural food colorings include beetroot juice for red color, turmeric for yellow, and spirulina for green. However, they can be less stable and harder to work with. Their use requires adjustments in the recipe or processing methods to achieve the desired color.

Another alternative to synthetic food coloring is avoiding it altogether, particularly in homemade recipes or small-scale food production. Using natural colorants can often result in a more authentic and visually appealing product and enhance the flavor and overall experience of the dish.

Food-Coloring-6

How do I choose the right food coloring for my dish?

The choice of food coloring depends largely on the desired color, recipe requirements, and personal preferences. If you prefer a natural food coloring, consider factors such as color intensity, stability, and compatibility with other ingredients. Some natural colorants may require higher concentrations or special handling to achieve the desired shade.

On the other hand, if a synthetic dye is used, ensure it is appropriate for the intended application, such as high heat resistance for baking or a suitable pH range for acidic recipes. Consult a food scientist or read product labels for guidance on selecting the right food coloring for your recipe.

Are there any tips for working with food coloring?

  1. Always use food-grade coloring agents, as non-food-grade products can be toxic and pose health risks. 2. Read the product label thoroughly to ensure compatibility with your recipe and any potential restrictions on use. 3. Measure the coloring agent accurately to avoid over- or under-coloring. Start with a small amount and adjust as needed.
  2. Be aware of the color-changing properties of some natural food colorants like beetroot juice, which can change color when combined with other ingredients or heated. 5. Consider the color intensity and stability of the food coloring when selecting a recipe. Some recipes may require additional colorant or specialized processing to achieve the desired color.

As an Amazon Affiliate, we earn through qualifying purchases at no cost to you.

--

--